Journal

Why don't monsters disappear from stories?

If present-day humanity could rewrite all the fairy tales in the world, what would it remove from them first? The dragon, Cerberus, the Minotaur, the troll under the bridge, the sphinx? If we took them out of the story and left the treasure in a clearing, in plain sight, anyone could reach it. But in that very moment, almost all stories would stop being interesting.

There is a pattern so widespread that it is easy to stop noticing it. In stories, the most important things are not left within anyone's reach. Before them, almost invariably, a guardian appears. Sometimes it is a dragon, sometimes a sphinx or a troll. Whether we change the continent, the religion, or the age, the rule remains the same: what is truly valuable is not only hidden, it is guarded. At first glance, the guardian exists for suspense. Without it, the hero would reach the destination too easily, and the story would lose its tension. But if that were its only role, a locked door or a wall would have been enough. That is why almost all great stories choose something else - they place a living being in front of the hero, as if finding the road were not enough, as if one also had to prove oneself worthy of walking it. The guardian is almost always there before the hero appears. The dragon does not wake up one morning and say, "Today someone is coming for the gold." Cerberus is not waiting only for Orpheus. The sphinx does not exist only for Oedipus. They are there from the beginning, as if every generation had to pass through the same threshold. It is not a test invented for one person alone, but one that human beings encounter again and again under different faces. Perhaps this is where the true function of the guardian is hidden: it does not guard the gold, the castle, or the world beyond; it guards the conditions under which one may reach them.

In the reality outside fairy tales, things are not very different. A doctor is not given the right to operate without years of training. A pilot does not take the controls of an airplane simply because they want to. A musician does not step onto a stage simply because they love music. In all these situations there is a trial, not in order to make the path harder, but in order to protect the value of the thing to which it leads. An exam does not exist to protect the diploma, but to protect its meaning. Perhaps the dragon, or any other guardian, plays the same role. It is not an arbitrary obstacle placed in the hero's way; it is the trial without which the treasure would lose its symbolic value. Seen from this perspective, the fight with the monster is no longer only a confrontation with an external danger. It becomes a confrontation with one's own limits. Not because the dragon guards the gold from people, but because it prevents people from reaching it before they are ready. That is why each guardian is different. Not because the stories are different, but because valuable things require different qualities. Some require courage, others patience, others wisdom, others renunciation. There is no single exam for all treasures, because each of them has its own guardian. This may be why we sometimes feel that life places the same obstacle before us again and again. The workplace changes, but not the humiliation. The relationship changes, but not the disappointment. The circumstances change, but not the fear. And yet, although we feel that the obstacle is repeating itself, what is truly repeating is the exam.

This is where the real lesson that stories have repeated for thousands of years begins: not that the world is full of monsters, but that value is never separated from transformation. The hero does not return changed because he found the treasure. He returns changed because, before he could touch it, he was forced to become the person capable of reaching it. That is why dragons, sphinxes, and cerberi have never disappeared from our stories. Not because human beings have always believed in monsters, but because they sensed something much harder to accept: there are things that cannot be received before they have been earned. This is the true reason why almost all cultures have placed a guardian before the things that truly matter, to remind us that some gates do not open with a key. They open with the person you have become by the time you arrive before them.

- RN

Back to Journal